Lab Report 011 – Commander Deck Fatigue Is Real

by MaD SaXXon, Tibalt’s Apprentice

I have over 30 Commander decks—and I’m adding more even as I write this. This may be too many.

Back when I was going out to play twice a week, it made sense. I could rotate through up to six decks per session, test ideas, revisit old favorites, and always keep things fresh. But now? I’ve played exactly one paper game in the last two months. A handful of matches on SpellTable, sure, but the rhythm just isn’t there.

So now I’m stuck with this weird pressure: dismantle some decks to focus on a few? That feels like I’m being forced to have fun with what’s left—and that kind of forced fun never really works. In the past, the abundance of both play opportunities and deck options gave me peace of mind. If a game flopped or a deck bricked, no big deal. There was always next time.

But now “next time” isn’t guaranteed.

I’m not writing this because I have the answer. I’m not even sure there is a problem to solve. Maybe this is just part of being a longtime player in a game that’s changed so much. Maybe it’s just a side effect of loving this hobby a lot—maybe too much.

So what do you think, dear reader?
How many decks are too many?
Is it better to have a few you love or a library you rotate through?

Let me know if you’ve found the sweet spot. Or if, like me, you’re still looking for it.

— MaD SaXXon, Tibalt’s Apprentice

Comments

The Weakest Deck at the Table Still Wins (Supplement)

The Weakest Deck at the Table Still Wins I don't usually do this. Most of what I make lives in the video and stays there. But the deck tech format only gives me so much room — rapid-fire card talk doesn't leave space for the why behind the picks, and some of that why is worth more than a soundbite. So I'm trying something new: a written companion piece to go with the video, digging into the parts that didn't fit. If this is useful, let me know — I'd like to know whether it's worth doing again for future videos, or whether it's better left as a one-off. I don't remember the games this deck has lost. That's not me being modest, and it's not selective bragging either — it's just true. I can tell you the exact turn Whiptongue Hydra cleared a sky full of dragons. I can tell you what it felt like when a $25 deck put a $400 deck in the graveyard. Ask me about a loss, though, and I've got nothing specific. My brain doesn't file those aw...

Nobody's Coming for You Personally (And That's Why You Should Play Harder) Derrick from Super Fast Tortoise said something on his morning show that made me stop and think: he wants to play more assertively. Maybe even aggressively. My first instinct was the same one every Commander player has: careful, that's how arms races start. I don't think that's true. Here's why. Two Different Levers "Assertive play" is a mindset. How you pilot. Develop every turn. Take the line instead of waiting for a safer one. Apply pressure. You can do all of that with a Bracket 2 precon. An "arms race" is a deckbuilding problem. Cards getting swapped for stronger cards, session after session, until nobody's having fun even though everyone's winning more. Two different levers. You can pull one without the other. I've watched a totally passive stax pile — hold everything up, combo off turn twenty — that's more of an arms-race deck than an a...

The Slopification of Magic: The Gathering — A Game Eating Itself

If you've been playing since the Urza block, the Mirrodin era, the original Ravnica, or even just early Innistrad — you know what I mean. You remember what it felt like when a new set dropped and it felt like a gift, not a product launch. That feeling isn't gone. But it's getting harder to find. The Slopification of Magic: The Gathering — A Game Eating Itself By a long-time player who remembers what it used to feel like There's a word floating around internet culture right now: slop . It refers to the flood of low-effort, algorithmically-generated, quantity-over-quality content that increasingly drowns out anything made with genuine care. We see it in AI-generated images, in streaming content, in fast fashion. And if you've been playing Magic: The Gathering for more than a few years, you've been watching it happen to your favorite card game — slowly at first, then all at once. I've been playing Magic for a long time. Long enough to remember when a ...

Lab Notes!

Search This Blog